Skip to content
Published studies are shown for demonstration purposes, not because they are good or bad research. Demonstrator · items marked Example are invented · what exists today
Search

Skills · e2er bundled skills

Constructive Feedback Review — Best Practices

By e2er authors

Transform raw feedback (which may be harsh, dismissive, or unconstructively negative) into a professional, constructive review. The output should be honest about weaknesses but always actionable, respectful, and oriented toward improvement. The goal: the author reads the review and knows exactly what to fix and feels motivated to do so.

In the catalogue
No evaluations yet
Anyone can contribute. Improve this skill Contribute a skill

Provenance

Project
e2er bundled skills
Maintained by
e2er authors
Licence
MIT
Source file
bhanneke/E2ER-project/blob/v0.16.1/skills/files/review/constructive-feedback.md
Identifier
e2er/review/constructive-feedback

Use it

Ships with every installation of e2er.

Cite this skill
Persistent identifiers planned 
@software{e2erauthors2026constructivefeedbackrevi,
  title   = {Constructive Feedback Review — Best Practices},
  author  = {e2er authors},
  year    = {2026},
  note    = {e2er skill. Persistent identifier planned},
  url     = {https://github.com/bhanneke/E2ER-project/blob/v0.16.1/skills/files/review/constructive-feedback.md}
}
 Report a failure

Used by

No e2er specialist loads this skill by default. Once installed, a template can assign it to a specialist.

Description

Data model
Discipline
Economics
Method family
not specified
Design
not specified
Research stage
Review
Authors
e2er authors (Software, Methodology)
Usage
not used in published research yet
Source
e2er repository · skills/files · @d8fd8ab
Record
skill:e2er/review/constructive-feedback · JSON

Solid tags are declared by the source or mapped from its terms; dashed tags are inferred by a published rule. Hover a tag for its provenance.

More

reviewMIT

Evaluations

Planned

No evaluation record yet. An evaluation shows where a skill breaks before others rely on it.

Evaluate this skill

More review skills in e2er bundled skills

Consistency CheckData Review Checklist for Empirical EconomicsDomain plausibility reviewMethods review (any discipline)Referee SimulationReference CheckTechnical ReviewAcademic Writing Review Checklist

On e2er.org

Loading…

Report a failurePropose a new version

Discussion

Loading…