Empirical study, pre-registered
The empirical template with the researcher in it: a design review, a pre-registration frozen before any estimation, and a review of the draft.
Where it sits
left: what it builds on · right: what builds on it · pale: exampleBy e2er authors
How studies reach it
- Exchange outages and crypto bid-ask s… → Event study in finance → Empirical study, pre-registeredExample
- Attention shocks and small-cap mispri… → Event study in finance → Empirical study, pre-registeredExample
- Late-evening disclosures and next-day… → Event study in finance → Empirical study, pre-registeredExample
- Earnings announcements and retail tra… → Event study in finance → Empirical study, pre-registeredExample
- Stablecoins and the cost of remittanc… → Earnings announcements and retail tra… → Event study in finance → Empirical study, pre-registeredExample
Disciplines it reaches
Solid: published studies. Light: examples.
Computed from the records on this site: what each study, template and specialist names as used, which study extends which, and who authored what. 5 studies in total.
- Input
- A research question, your data and your literature
- Output
- A draft paper with a frozen pre-registration, a replication package and a dossier
- At the end
- When any run ends, e2er builds the PDF, writes the audit trail and the structured export, and pushes to GitHub if you set that up.
Steps
Greyed steps do not run in the selected mode.
- 1 your reviewDesign reviewRight after the design specialists, before anything else runs: the researcher reads the plan, edits it, gives instructions or sends a specialist back.
- 2 your reviewPre-registrationQuestion, hypotheses, identification and analysis plan, assembled into preregistration.md and frozen with its fingerprint on approval, still before any estimation.
- 3 specialistsDesign, data, estimation and draftPlans the paper and dispatches specialists for the literature, data, identification strategy, econometric specification, analysis and drafting.
- 4 specialistsImprove until it stops getting betterFurther rounds of the strategist, revisiting design and analysis.
- 5 checkEstimation checkChecks the estimation against the specification declared before it ran. Halts the run on failure.
- 6 your reviewDraft reviewThe researcher reads the draft after the draft and the estimation gate, before the reviewers read it.
- 7 specialists
- 8 specialists, parallelPolishFive specialists polish formulas, numbers, institutional detail, equilibria and the bibliography.
- 9 reviewers, parallelReview panelNumbers and citations are checked first. Six reviewers (mechanism, technical, literature, data, identification, writing) then score the draft.
- 10 specialistsRevisionRevises the draft in response to the reviews, as a full revision and as targeted edits.
- 11 specialists
Technical details
Template id empirical-preregistered · file pipelines/empirical-preregistered.toml, checked against pipeline.schema.json.
| Step | Id in the template file | Specialists |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Design review | review_design | |
| 2. Pre-registration | preregister | |
| 3. Design, data, estimation and draft | initial | idea_developer, literature_scanner, data_architect, identification_strategist, econometrics_specialist, data_analyst, paper_drafter |
| 4. Improve until it stops getting better | iterative | |
| 5. Estimation check | estimation_gate | |
| 6. Draft review | review_draft | |
| 7. Self-critique | self_attack | self_attacker |
| 8. Polish | polish | polish_formula, polish_numerics, polish_institutions, polish_equilibria, polish_bibliography |
| 9. Review panel | review | mechanism_reviewer, technical_reviewer, literature_reviewer, data_reviewer, identification_reviewer, writing_reviewer |
| 10. Revision | revision | revisor, patch_revisor |
| 11. Replication package | replication | replication_packager |
At the end (finalize): compile, audit_export, github_push, structured_export. Modes: single_pass, iterative.
More
A fork of the empirical study template. It keeps its steps and adds design review, pre-registration and draft review.
Description
Data model- Discipline
- Economics
- Method family
- Empirical (quantitative)
- Design
- not specified
- Research stage
- ReviewRevision and editingReplicationResearch questionLiterature synthesisData acquisitionResearch designData analysisDrafting
- Authors
- e2er authors (Software, Methodology)
- Usage
- forked 1 time
- Source
- e2er repository · pipelines/empirical-preregistered.toml · @v0.11.0
- Record
- template:empirical-preregistered · JSON
Solid tags are declared by the source or mapped from its terms; dashed tags are inferred by a published rule. Hover a tag for its provenance.
Versions and evaluations
One version, unreleasedOne version so far: pipelines/empirical-preregistered.toml in e2er 0.11.0. No evaluation records exist yet.
Connectors this template can use
What a run of this template can reach outside your machine, and what each sends out.
Checks on this template
- ✓Output contracts · Every step produced the artifact it declared, in the declared form
Required of every template. - ✓Execution reliability · Analysis code ran and wrote a parseable, non-empty result
Required of every template. - ○Numbers · Every number in tables and text matches the output of executed code
Proposed. Proposed for the floor; runs log it but may not block on it. - ○Citations · Every reference resolves to an existing publication via OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar or Crossref
Proposed. Proposed for the floor; runs log it but may not block on it. - ○Verbatim passages · Every claim about a source points to a passage found word for word in that source
Proposed. Proposed for the floor; runs log it but may not block on it.
Runs of this template
No runs yet.
Use it
Install e2er as described on the Install page, then start a run:
e2er run "<your research question>" --template empirical-preregisteredFrom e2er 0.11.0. Get started goes from install to publish.
On e2er.org
Loading…
Discussion
Loading…